Troy movie vs history

How does the film about troy in greek mythology differ. The tale of troy begins with the competition among the three goddesses, which aphrodite won. The movie s closing titles state that the film was inspired by the iliad of homer, but the end of the film is based loosely on book 2 of the aeneid of virgil. Whats the difference between the iliad the book and troy the movie.

At the start of the next shot, as the camera begins to pan down, on the far right, just beside a persons who is dressed in blue head is a metal bullhorn ie. Homers sprawling tale of love and war in ancient greece comes to the screen in all its grandeur in this epicscale adventure. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. The viewer is made aware that achilles does not want to fight the trojans for agamemnon.

Hes going to take the beach of troy with fifty men. Due to the political situation in iraq, the location for scale shots was moved from morocco to mexico, an ideal alternate choice with its broad beach. What are the differences between the movie troy and the. The whole movie shows their battle struggles and the foreshadowing of fate in this adaptation of homers classic the iliad. The trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean greek kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc. There are several inaccuracies in the 2004 film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson and starring brad pitt and eric bana. Troy is an overlooked epic that doesnt deserve the rotten rating it received. Better a couple of hundred sweaty warriors than two masses of 50,000 men marching toward one another across a sea. Tale of troy or iliad the story behind the trojan war. The differences between the book iliad and the movie troy.

This movie, troy, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers. Without the hand of apollo to guide the arm of paris, achilles should have survived and might well have lived long enough. How does the film about troy in greek mythology differ from. The trojan war, your probably heard about this episode in history due to the well known movie.

Produced by units in malta, mexico and britains shepperton studios, the film features an ensemble cast led by brad pitt, eric bana, and orlando bloom. Last may, wolfgang petersen directed a movie based on the iliad. Boagrius fight, for its dynamic camera and originality. Whether the trojan war actually took place there is a matter of debate. Get an answer for what are the differences between the movie troy and the iiliad. Troy is a 2004 epic historical war drama film directed by wolfgang petersen and written by david benioff. When examined meticulously, it is clearly evident however, that the film troy, is historically accurate as it is based on true facts from the ancient greek life. Based on homers iliad, this epic portrays the battle between the ancient kingdoms of troy and sparta.

D the trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean greek kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc. As achilles ship nears the trojan shores, agamemnon snidely asks, whats the fool doing. Troy is an ancient city in turkey that has long been identified as being the. Another difference between the iliad and troy is the history between achilles and king agamemnon. Troy i first stonewalled village settlement 2550 bce 2300 bce. Meneleuss death, pariss escape, helens situation, and the trojan princesses. Is not known for sure if this episode happened as it was presented, but,in greek mythology. The iliad verses troy i n the movie its stated that agamemnon brought the kings together for this war, which really isnt true. Spears in the film were constructed in such a manner that they looked like they were supposed. Troy movie simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. Professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who. The literary characters and events must be classified as legendary. Similarities and differences between the history behind the trojan war compared to the movie. Troy is an adaptation of homers great epic, the film follows the assault on troy by the united greek forces and chronicles the fates of the men. A film that is historically inaccurate gives no benefit to its viewers as the story can be so twisted and changed that it is no longer, a tale of history, tradition or culture. Dec 06, 2015 ancient history documentary the true story of troy an ancient war documentary the greek mythology is fascinating. Priam is not killed by agamemnon but by neoptolimus, achilles son. Quora user i disagree with you about the second point of view you put forward.

Briseis is not taken away from achilles until after the war has begun. Wolfgang petersens 2004 film, troy, isnt historically accurate and it isnt faithful to its literary source. Apr 22, 2018 the trojan war, your probably heard about this episode in history due to the well known movie. Troy, fall of a city, recently launched, while turkey designated 2018 the year of troy and plans a year of celebration, including the. Troy is based on the epic poem the iliad by homer, according to the credits. Brad pitt, eric bana, orlando bloom, julian glover. For the best experience please update your browser. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the. The battle of megiddo was the first reliably recorded battle, and not long after the battle of kadesh would claim the title of the largest chariot battle ever, despite chariot warfare persisting for nearly 1,000 more years. In greek mythology, the trojan war was waged against the city of troy by the achaeans. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film.

According to calculations given by eratosthenes, a famous greek scholar, this day in 1184 bc saw the fall of troy after the trojan war. Jun 11, 2017 in the 150 years since, historians and archaeologists have been forced to conclude, for the most part, that something did happen at the site of troy in the early 12th century bc, and even that the exact dates proposed by the greek scholar eratosthenes might be accurate. The movie sidesteps the existence of the greek gods, turns its heroes into action movie cliches and demonstrates that were getting tired of computergenerated armies. Troy ii origin of gold treasure found by schliemann. Turkeys culture ministry has invited some of the actors from the 2004 epic hollywood movie troy to lend the event some star power. In the lba records mentioning troy begin to appear in other cultures. The new, eightpart netflix historical drama series, troy. Some pieces of materials will be quoted to support my understanding that in the iliad of homer, briseis is more than an object in achilless eyes. An adaptation of homers great epic, the film follows the assault on troy by the united greek forces and chronicles the fates of the men involved.

Fall of a city, debuted this week on the streaming service, after running in the united kingdom on bbc one in february. So they set off with 1,000 ships holding 50,000 greeks to troy. He acted as leader of the trojans and their allies in the defence of troy, killing 31,000 greek fighters. Achilles duels hector who killed his cousin, patroclus hd movie scene from the directors cut of wolfgang petersens troy i do not own the content of this. Troy movie, certain decisions were made that had dramatic and, depending on how you look at the troy movie, devastating consequences. Jul 03, 2017 achilles duels hector who killed his cousin, patroclus hd movie scene from the directors cut of wolfgang petersens troy i do not own the content of this. Meanwhile, hector and paris return to troy with helen, greeted warmly by their fellow trojans. The iliad over the thousands of years that the epic story the iliad has survived, there has no doubt been some form of alteration to homers original. The ancient history encyclopedia logo is a registered eu trademark. The 2004 epic film troy catches quite the break when it comes to historical films. Chief among these was the elimination of the involvement of the gods and goddesses in the lives of men at troy. Alexander, the king of macedonia and one of the greatest army leaders in the history of warfare, conquers much of the known world. Briseis is a trojan priestess and hectors cousin, captured during the attack on apollos temple.

Odysseus persuasion speech for its remarkable portrayal of ancient greek competitive, glory seeking eth. How the movie troy doesnt even come close to historys history. Egyptian warfare and the largest chariot battle in history. The story of the trojan warthe bronze age conflict between the kingdoms of troy and mycenaean greecestraddles the history and mythology of ancient greece and. Coastal mexico is an endangered turtle habitat, so to be granted permission to set up the greek encampment and build boats on the large stretch of beach, the film crew implemented. Agamemnon attacks troy out of his own greed and ambition. There are many inaccuracies in the historical events depicted in troy, according to the historians. These two have this conflict because paris, prince of troy, fell in love with helen, wife of menelaus who is agamemnons brother and king of sparta, and took her back to troy against the wishes of his brother, hector, who, with his father, had been trying for years to make peace. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film the guardian. Better a couple of hundred sweaty warriors than two masses of 50,000 men marching toward one another across a sea of.

The movie troy showed that the trojan war was caused over helen the wife of menelaus king of sparta who was secretly having an affair with the youngest son of the king of troy prince paris who smuggled helen onboard their homeland vessel much to his older brothers. Rachel browne, in the australian sun herald may 23, 2004. The themes of the movie troy is being remembered throughout history or having immortality. Ancient history documentary the true story of troy an ancient. The trojans, thinking that the greeks had sailed away and left the horse as a. The trojan war explained as short as possible youtube. If so, that would place the fall of the city on 11 june 1184 bc. In an attempt to make one of history s greatest epic sagas manageable on screen, the movie tells us both too much and too little about what is going on and keeps reminding us about everyones passion for a place in history but does not show us enough about who the characters are and why their destinies are so entangled. Well learn about the characters in each version and how the.

To understand the battle of kadesh it is important to know how the egyptian army and their chariots operated. If you liked troy, youll idolize these 10 greatest war. However, the rushed decision presented some obstacles. The movie troy is about the conflict between the greek citystates, led by agamemnon, and troy, ruled by priam.

Classics analysis the iliad vs troy sunday, 14 october 2012. Elena gottesman, rachel lee, and taylor wilson the trojan horse historical accuracy during the war, the greeks moved their ships and hid inside of a hollow wooden horse. While it certainly doesnt have big emotion that we would expect from these kind of movies. Helen had many powerful suitors and her father was too afraid to pick one of them for her husband in fear of offending the others. The war is one of the most important events in greek mythology and has been narrated through many works of greek literature, most notably homers iliad. For example, there is a return to handmade pottery after centuries of wares made on the wheel. The trojan war was seen as one of the most important events of the ancient world, ignited by the stealing of helen by paris of troy from her husband, the king of sparta, menelaus. The ancient greeks believed that troy was located near the dardanelles and that the trojan war was a historical event of the th or 12th century bc, but by the mid19th century ad, both the war and the city were widely seen as nonhistorical.

If he goes to troy, he will find his eternal glory and history will remember his name for thousands of years. This is also portrayed in the movie troy as when hector faces achilles in one on one combat, they use their spears first and then their swords. Troy is a 2004 epic historical war drama film directed by wolfgang petersen and written by. May 14, 2004 troy is based on the epic poem the iliad by homer, according to the credits. James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. He feels that agamemnon wants to fight this war for greed and not honor. Major differences between the homers iliad and the film troy. In this lesson, well discuss the differences and similarities between homers the iliad and wolfgang petersens 2004 film troy.

Troy the movie research paper emmanuel heen troy movie vs. It is full of powerful gods like zeus, athena, hera and aphrodite, brave heroes. It stars brad pitt as achilles, eric bana as hector, and peter otoole as king priam. Troy is a 2004 angloamerican action movie about the trojan war. Film analysis troy 2004 historical accuracy of troy uk essays. Troy viii and troy ix are dated to historical periods. Aug 26, 2017 troy is an ancient city in turkey that has long been identified as being the setting for homers the iliad. The wooden horse and the sack of troy do not appear in the iliad which ends shortly after the funeral of hector. In sparta, prince hector and his young brother paris want troy and sparta to have peace but there is a war.

Dr blanche menadier is an honorary research associate at macquarie university who has excavated at troy nine times. Film analysis troy 2004 historical accuracy of troy. Agamemnon is inspired to attack troy by a dream sent by the gods, who want to bring his army misery for taking briseis away from achilles. While visiting spartan king menelaus brendan gleeson, trojan prince paris orlando bloom falls for menelaus wife, helen diane kruger, and takes her back to troy. The iliad is the retelling by homer of a part of the trojan war.

In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy. The legendary ancient city of troy is very much in the limelight this year. Looking at its historical accuracy, we can find the good and bad representations as well as the truly ugly decisions that truly twist history. With the help of achilles, the greeks are able to fight the never before defeated trojans. Feb 06, 2017 quora user i disagree with you about the second point of view you put forward.